International Journal for Quality in Health Care 14:149-153 (2002)
© 2002 International Society for Quality in Health Care
Patient compliance with managed care emergency department referral: an orthopaedic view
1Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholars Program, University of California, Los Angeles
2Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Kaiser Permanente Southern California, Bellflower
3Center for Health Policy Research, University of California, Los Angeles, CA, USA
Address reprints requests to Don Saroff PO Box 910 Derby Line Vermont 05830-0910 USA. E-mail: donsaroff{at}earthlink.net
Objective. Patient compliance with emergency department (ED) generated referral is an important part of the delivery of quality health care. Although many studies from non-managed care health centers have reported on ED patient compliance, no studies have reported on this in a managed care setting. The objective of this study is to examine patient compliance with ED-generated referral and to produce a benchmark of follow-up rates possible in a capitated managed care system. That is to say, in a health care system whose members pay a uniform per capita payment or fee, one that has salaried physicians, owns its own hospitals, and has a mechanism of transition from ED to outpatient clinic that ensures referral accessibility.
Design. Retrospective review of consecutive ED patient compliance with ED-generated referral.
Patients/methods. All consecutive patients who presented to a managed care hospital’s ED with an acute fracture and who were given an outpatient referral during the period from 23rd December 1998 to 23rd January, 1999. Of 8000 consecutive ED patients, 234 were included in the study. Compliance with ED-generated referral was determined from outpatient clinic records.
Results. Of the 234 patients treated in the ED and referred, 222 (94.9%) complied with follow-up appointments.
Conclusions. We have demonstrated that an ED patient follow-up compliance rate of 94.9% can be obtained. It is probable that the high compliance rate is due to the features of the system studied. The high rate may also be related to the specific diagnosis studied, although previous literature reports poor ED patient compliance for the same diagnosis in a different ED setting. Additional research is needed to determine whether the high compliance rate reported in this study can be obtained in ED settings that are not part of a similar managed care system and to determine the role of referral accessibility (or inaccessibility) in current ED settings.
Keywords: access, compliance, emergency department, fracture